Monday, November 16, 2026

Head before heart? Cognitive empathy may emerge before affective empathy in the developing brain

We usually assume empathy starts with feeling: a child sees another child cry, feels distress, and only later learns to understand what the other person is going through. A study from Bulgarelli, Pinti, Bazelmans, Hamilton and Jones (Birkbeck, UCL and King’s College London) suggests the order may run the other way. 

The authors measured cortical activity (functional near-infrared spectroscopy, fNIRS) and heart rate in about 90 preschoolers aged 3 to 6. The children watched short picture stories in which a child character met happy, sad or neutral events. Being asked how the character felt (cognitive empathy) engaged medial and dorsolateral prefrontal cortex and parietal regions, a network much like the adult “mentalizing” system. Emotional rather than neutral events (affective empathy) engaged the left superior temporal gyrus. Activation for cognitive empathy was relatively stronger in the youngest children, and activation for affective empathy was stronger in the older ones. The authors take this to mean that understanding another’s emotion comes online before, or alongside, sharing it. Negative scenarios also slowed children’s heart rates more than positive ones.

The study compares younger and older children at a single time point rather than following the same children as they grow. So “head before heart” is an inference from age differences, not an observed sequence. fNIRS also can’t see deeper structures such as the insula and amygdala, which are central to feeling. Still, the result fits nicely with recent MindBlog posts on the two sides of empathy falling out of balance. If the two components come online at different times, they can presumably also come apart later in life. 

No comments:

Post a Comment